Skip to main content

The Bluest Eye and "Playing in the Dark"

The contrast between characters written by Morrison and Black characters that are written by white authors is striking. Morrison’s characters are richly imagined and authentic. They are there to tell their stories, not to serve as surrogates who allow white writers to express their own forbidden feelings and desires while still maintaining white standards for their white characters. After reading both The Bluest Eye and “Playing in the Dark,” I came across a short BookRiot article entitled “7 Casually Racist Things That White Writers Do” (Nunnaly, 2018) that highlighted some issues that still occur in literature and film. 

"Non-white characters always have some form of description to make sure their non-whiteness is made clear, usually via a description of skin tone. It becomes problematic, however, when there isn't a comparable descriptor for any of the white characters. The absence of that description (really the absence of race) IS the trigger for the reader to understand that the character is white." (Harleston, 2018)

One thing that I notice frequently appears as item 3 on Nunnaly’s list: “when introducing characters, only the non-white races are mentioned.” This is so common that many people only notice when it is not the case. I have also found that when I do see all characters being introduced with race, or none, the piece is almost always written by a BIPOC writer. White writers rarely feel the need to identify a character as white because white is seen as the “default” in U.S. culture. According to Renee Harleston in “Dismantling the White Default” (2018), ‘“white as default’ is when whiteness is the litmus test for what is considered normal behavior, culture, and appearance.” We can see this “white as default” idea in The Bluest Eye, but Morrison is not writing it as a white writer would. Instead, she is using the idea to raise awareness of it as an issue: white should not be the standard. Not in beauty, or culture, or clothing, or food, or lifestyle. 


Images of Black Hermione

We find one modern example of how literature’s “white default” can be turned on its head in the original West End stage production of J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. Until the production was cast, the character of Hermione Granger had been considered canonically white and had been played by a white actor. However, in the books, Hermione is never specifically described as white. She is described as having brown eyes, “bushy” hair, and large teeth, and after one vacation she comes back looking “very brown.” She is described as having a “white face” only one time, and that is during a description of a moment of fear. When adult Hermione was cast in the play, she was portrayed by black actor Noma Dumezweni. While this caused controversy, it also exposed society’s assumption of white default.

While young women need to see themselves reflected in media, non-white girls need to see depictions of themselves that are not just brown-skinned versions of white characters. They also need to see characters that are not stereotypes or "token characters of color." While white writers need to be aware of and avoid the white default, we can also promote authentic characters by amplifying the non-white writers who create them.

References

Harleston, Renee. "Dismantling the White Default." Writing Diversely, November 12, 2022. https://www.writingdiversely.com/post/dismantling-the-white-default#:~:text=Answer%3A%20Constructing%20and%20perpetuating%20a,%2C%20politics...etc.

"Harry Potter and the Fact That Hermione is Black" (image). Nerds of Color, December 21, 2015. https://thenerdsofcolor.org/2015/12/21/harry-potter-and-the-fact-that-hermione-is-black/

Nunnaly, Mya. "7 Casually Racist Things That White Writers Do." BookRiot, February 5, 2018. https://bookriot.com/casually-racist-things-that-white-authors-do/

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Bluest Eye and Reading Primers

  Mike, Pam, Penny, and Father In The Bluest Eye , Toni Morrison explores the dynamic between white standards of beauty, womanhood, home life, and family and the realities of her characters. She uses the classic Dick and Jane primers as a visual of those white standards: two heterosexual, middle-class parents and three very blonde children who are always clean and well-dressed. This family experiences only minor interpersonal conflicts, and the children have lives that are defined by safety and playtime. The mother stays at home and cares for the children, while the father works outside the home and returns at dinnertime and on weekends. These children do not know hunger, or cold, or pain, or fear. Morrison contrasts this with the lives of her characters, who view these storybooks as “how life is supposed to be” even though their experiences are nothing like those of Dick, Jane, and Baby. So many young children of color learned to read with Dick and Jane primers, but these books d...
Post a Comment
Read more

Reclaiming the F-Word (The Body: Creativity, Control, and Power)

“Militant. Radical. Man-hating.” ( Bennet, 2014 ) Is this what feminism means in our culture? In Brancaccio, Mehta, and Menendez’s article, “ Most Millennials Believe in Gender Equity, but Avoid the ‘Feminist’ Label ” the authors discuss how many young people shy away from describing themselves as feminists. My classmates and I felt that this was partly due to negative connotations surrounding the word, and presented ideas for how to overcome this stigma and how to reframe the feminist label as a positive one. One of the suggestions was that we must use the media to begin to take control of the narrative surrounding feminism. As I read further about this issue, I realized that is already happening in U.S. culture. Jason LaVeris—FilmMagic/Getty Images Beyonce is an example of how feminism is being redefined for the younger generations. She was the focus of another article that we read in this module (LaVoulle and Ellison’s “The Bad Bitch Barbie Craze and Beyonce” in Taboo , Fall 2017), ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Women Creating Culture

This week we discussed women as cultural legends. Some of these cultural myths were based on real women, but all of the stories and images have been fictionalized to promote a patriarchal agenda and to satisfy the male gaze. In the modern era, feminists have been trying to rewrite these legends to turn these women into feminist heroes.  La Llorona by Angela Yarber One such feminist retelling can be found in Sandra Cisneros’ short story “ Woman Hollering Creek ” (1991). Set on the actual Woman Hollering Creek in Seguin, TX, this story reimagines the La Llorona myth. Where the traditional story casts La Llorona as a tragic character at best, and a monster at worst, Cisneros’ main character, Cleofilas, finds the strength to leave her abusive husband in search of a better life for herself and her child. She does not want to end her story as a victim, but instead accepts the help of another woman to take charge of her life and pursue a happier ending.  “When I look at la Virgen de ...
Post a Comment
Read more