Good Girls and Sex: Just Say "No!"

"It's kind of a double-edged sword, isn't it? If you say you haven't, you're a prude. If you say you have, you're a slut. It's a trap. You want to, but you can't. And when you did, you wish you hadn't." Allison (Aly Sheedy), The Breakfast Club, 1985

Allison and Claire, The Breakfast Club, 1985

In film, we see several stereotypes related to women and sexuality. One example is Claire in The Breakfast Club. Although she is clearly uncomfortable with conversations about sex, the other characters push her with questions about her sexual history (or lack of sexual experience). The other female character, Allison, explains the dilemma "good girls" face: if you don't have sex, you're considered an uptight prude, but if you do, you're considered a whore. This "good girl" trope is often used in horror movies, where the sole survivor (the Final Girl) is either a virgin or a non-sexualized, chaste woman who keeps her clothes on and avoids drugs and alcohol. Promiscuous female characters, and those who behave badly by drinking or doing drugs, are the women who become victims of the antagonist.

Virginal "Final Girl" Nancy Thompson (Heather Langenkamp) in A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984)

Many of our media representations of "good girls" are also tied to race. In a 2014 article for Rewire, Erika L. Sanchez asserts that the "good girl" image frequently seen in pop music is almost exclusively white: for instance, stars such as Debbie Gibson, Britney Spears, Miley Cyrus, and Taylor Swift. While several of these artists have since worked to shed the "good girl" image, Sanchez points out that you rarely see a black artist marked this way. Like many scholars of intersectional feminism, Sanchez notes that black women have been stereotyped as dangerous, sexually promiscuous, and deviant, whereas white, middle-class young women can be marketed as sexy, but still virginal in a way that is appealing to the male gaze. One exception to this is Whitney Houston, who was often marketed with a "good girl" image by the media and her label in her early career.

Whitney Houston as a young "good girl."

References

A Nightmare on Elm Street (image). 1984. Accessed at https://www.slashfilm.com/985113/the-scariest-scenes-in-a-nightmare-on-elm-street-movies/

Sanchez, Erika L. "Pop Music's 'Good Girl' Complex." Rewire News Group, February 6, 2014. https://rewirenewsgroup.com/2014/02/06/pop-musics-good-girls-complex/

The Breakfast Club (image), 1985. Accessed at https://filmdaze.substack.com/p/anti-queerness-and-the-pinkification

Whitney Houston. Accessed at https://www.theguardian.com/music/gallery/2012/feb/12/whitney-houston-in-pictures

Comments

The Bluest Eye and Reading Primers

Mike, Pam, Penny, and Father In The Bluest Eye , Toni Morrison explores the dynamic between white standards of beauty, womanhood, home life, and family and the realities of her characters. She uses the classic Dick and Jane primers as a visual of those white standards: two heterosexual, middle-class parents and three very blonde children who are always clean and well-dressed. This family experiences only minor interpersonal conflicts, and the children have lives that are defined by safety and playtime. The mother stays at home and cares for the children, while the father works outside the home and returns at dinnertime and on weekends. These children do not know hunger, or cold, or pain, or fear. Morrison contrasts this with the lives of her characters, who view these storybooks as “how life is supposed to be” even though their experiences are nothing like those of Dick, Jane, and Baby. So many young children of color learned to read with Dick and Jane primers, but these books d...

Reclaiming the F-Word (The Body: Creativity, Control, and Power)

“Militant. Radical. Man-hating.” ( Bennet, 2014 ) Is this what feminism means in our culture? In Brancaccio, Mehta, and Menendez’s article, “ Most Millennials Believe in Gender Equity, but Avoid the ‘Feminist’ Label ” the authors discuss how many young people shy away from describing themselves as feminists. My classmates and I felt that this was partly due to negative connotations surrounding the word, and presented ideas for how to overcome this stigma and how to reframe the feminist label as a positive one. One of the suggestions was that we must use the media to begin to take control of the narrative surrounding feminism. As I read further about this issue, I realized that is already happening in U.S. culture. Jason LaVeris—FilmMagic/Getty Images Beyonce is an example of how feminism is being redefined for the younger generations. She was the focus of another article that we read in this module (LaVoulle and Ellison’s “The Bad Bitch Barbie Craze and Beyonce” in Taboo , Fall 2017), ...

Eve

Dominichino, The Rebuke of Adam and Eve , 1626 While scholars such as Phyllis Trible (1973) have attempted to depatriarchalize Biblical interpretations to somehow reconcile faith and feminism, most feminist scholars who write about Christianity or the Bible consider the religion to be irrevocably tied to patriarchal values. For them, the story of Eve is the story of the beginning of the patriarchy. According to the Genesis account of the creation of humanity, God created Adam out of dust, in the image of God, and gave him dominion over all living things. However, God decided that Adam needed a helper, and created Eve from Adam's rib. While the creation from a rib -- from Adam's own flesh, and from his side -- may seem to imply that the two would be equals, standing side by side, Eve was not given dominion over living things as Adam was. While she was alone in the Garden, she listened to the advice of a serpent, who told her that if she ate the forbidden fruit from the Tree of...

Uncommon Historian

Search This Blog